Baked by Coley

BAKED Box by Baked by Coley

Freshly baked cookies, cookie sammies and brownies in a new seasonal theme monthly

No reviews yet
$29.95/month· Monthly
Deal: 20% off your first box with 3+ month prepay. Use code CRATEJOY20
Subscribe Now

Opens the box's official site. We may earn a commission.

About BAKED Box by Baked by Coley

Coley's BAKED Box sends freshly baked treats from family recipes, themed around the season or holiday each month. Every box includes two decorated sugar cookies, two cookie sammies (soft cookies sandwiched around a buttercream center), a brownie or blondie, two flavored cookies and one more treat, and the seller puts the retail value at $40. The flavors change every month, so subscribers get a mix of seasonal favorites and new recipes. Past boxes listed on Cratejoy show the range: a Halloween box with ghost and jack-o'-lantern sugar cookies, brownie sammies and a butterbeer cookie, a Thanksgiving box with turkey and pie-slice cookies, carrot cake sammies and a cranberry white chocolate blondie, a Christmas box with red velvet sammies and peppermint bark brownies, and a St. Patrick's Day box with mint chip brownies and pistachio white chocolate cookies. Boxes ship by UPS or USPS and arrive within 3 to 5 business days of shipping. New boxes typically ship in the first full week of the month, and orders placed after the 25th start with the next month's box. Holiday months can sell out. It is a sweet, low-effort gift for a cookie lover, a college student or a coworker, since the treats arrive ready to eat.

Why we like it

  • Freshly baked, ready-to-eat treats
  • 8 seasonal cookies, sammies and brownies per box
  • New theme and flavors every month
  • Ships by UPS or USPS; arrives in 3-5 business days